# IEC 61439 Verification Methods

By on

The (relatively new) switchgear and control gear standard, IEC 61439 'Low-voltage switchgear and controlgear assemblies' , ensures compliance to the standard by a series of design and routine verifications.

## Design Verifications

The standard has three methods which can be used to verify the design characteristics of an assembly will meet the standard. These are verification by test, verification by calculation and verification by the use of design rules.

The following table (table D.1 from Annex D of the standard, IEC:2011) summarizes each characteristic and the allowable options for design verification:

Verification options
No. Characteristics to be verified Clauses or
subclauses
Testing Calculation Design
Rules
1 Strength of materials and parts:
Resistance to corrosion
Properties of insulating materials:
Thermal stability
Resistance of insulating materials to abnormal
heat and fire due to internal electric effects
Resistance to ultraviolet (UV) radiation
Lifting
Mechanical impact
Marking
10.2
10.2.2
10.2.3
10.2.3.1
10.2.3.2

10.2.4
10.2.5
10.2.6
10.2.7

YES

YES
YES

YES
YES
YES
YES

NO

NO
NO

NO
NO
NO
NO

NO

NO
YES

YES
NO
NO
NO
2 Degree of protection of the enclosures 10.3 YES NO YES
3 Clearances 10.4 YES NO NO
4 Creepage distances 10.4 YES NO NO
5 Protection against electric shock and integrity
of protective circuits:
Effective continuity between the exposed conductive
parts of the assembly and the protective circuit
Short-circuit withstand strength of the protective
circuit
10.5

10.5.2

10.5.3

YES

YES

NO

YES

NO

NO
6 Incorporation of switching devices and components 10.6 NO NO YES
7 Internal electrical circuits and connections 10.7 NO NO YES
8 Terminals for external conductors 10.8 NO NO YES
9 Dielectric properties:
Power-frequency withstand voltage
Impulse withstand voltage
10.9
10.9.2
10.9.3

YES
YES

NO
NO

NO
YES
10 Temperature-rise limits 10.10 YES YES YES
11 Short-circuit withstand strength 10.11 YES YES NO
12 Electromagnetic compatibility (EMC) 10.12 YES NO YES
13 Mechanical operation 10.13 YES NO NO

## Routine Verification

Routine verification is carried out the detect faults in workmanship and the correct functioning of the panel.  The standard (IEC:2011) list the following:

1. Construction (see 11.2 to 11.8)
1. degree of protection of enclosures
2. clearances and creepage distances
3. protection against electric shock and integrity of protective circuits
4. incorporation of built-in components
5. internal electrical circuits and connections
6. terminals for external conductors
7. mechanical operation
2. Performance (see 11.9 to 11.10)
1. dielectric properties
2. wiring, operational performance and function

## Original and Assembly Manufacturer

IEC 61439 Verification, Courtesy ABB
The standard also tries to explain the differing roles of the original panel manufacturer and a assembly manufacturer.  The original manufacturer is the party who initially carries out the panel design and arranges for the necessary design verifications to be performed.  The assembly manufacturer is the party who finally builds the panel to the customers requirements and delivers it.    The image shows the relationship between the parties and who performs the verification.

Note: if an assembly manufacturer incorporates his own arrangements, he is then deemed to be the original manufacturer by the standard.

In addition to this post, you may also be interested in my post on 'Forms of Internal Separation' according to the standard:

Switchboard - Forms of Internal Separation

More interesting Notes:

Steven has over twenty five years experience working on some of the largest construction projects. He has a deep technical understanding of electrical engineering and is keen to share this knowledge. About the author

myElectrical Engineering

#### View 2 Comments (old system)

1. CM3PhaseDesign says:
2/21/2012 7:16 AM

Hi Steven.
I just wanted to confirm with you that the table D1 above is now out of date. With the issue of Edition 2 last year this table was amended.

You can see the current table on our website
http://www.3phasedesign.com/service.asp?i=48&t=Design%20Verification%20Table

• Steven says:
2/21/2012 8:28 AM

Thanks for pointing this out. I have updated the table to the 2011 edition.

Comments are closed for this post:
• have a question or need help, please use our Questions Section
• spotted an error or have additional info that you think should be in this post, feel free to Contact Us

## Latest Questions:

### Most Popular Notes:

Solar Electricity Handbook - 2015 Edition: ...
Michael Boxwell
Paperback - 204 pages
$16.47 Solar Energy: The Physics and Engineering ... Olindo Isabella, ... Kindle Edition - 488 pages Electric Power Distribution Engineering, ... Turan Gonen Hardcover - 1061 pages$104.97
Solar PV Engineering and Installation: ...
Sean White
Paperback - 248 pages
$37.95 Independent Energy Guide: Electrical Power ... Kevin Jeffrey Paperback - 280 pages Energy Systems Engineering: Evaluation and ... Francis Vanek, Louis ... Hardcover - 672 pages Renewable and Efficient Electric Power ... Gilbert M. Masters Hardcover - 712 pages$102.30
Photovoltaic Design and Installation For ...
Ryan Mayfield
Paperback - 384 pages
$16.99 Electric Power Substations Engineering, ... Hardcover - 536 pages$149.95
Do It Yourself 12 Volt Solar Power, 2nd ...
Michael Daniek
Paperback - 128 pages
$13.46 Submarine Power Cables: Design, ... Thomas Worzyk Paperback - 296 pages$189.00
Wind Turbine Operation in Electric Power ...
Zbigniew Lubosny
Paperback - 262 pages
$199.00 Power Generation Handbook 2/E Philip Kiameh Hardcover - 736 pages Power Quality in Power Systems and ... Ewald Fuchs, Mohammad ... Hardcover - 1140 pages$143.32
Smart Power Grids 2011 (Power Systems)
Hardcover - 696 pages
$299.00 Electrical Power System Essentials Pieter Schavemaker, ... Hardcover - 340 pages$86.00
Power System Monitoring and Control
Hassan Bevrani, ...
Hardcover - 288 pages
$119.00 Wind and Solar Power Systems Mukund R. Patel Hardcover - 368 pages Energy Systems Engineering: Evaluation and ... Francis Vanek, Louis ... Hardcover - 736 pages$96.93
Power Electronics for Modern Wind Turbines ...
Frede Blaabjerg, Zhe ...
Paperback - 120 pages
$27.22 Solar Power for Your Home (Green Guru ... David Findley Paperback - 208 pages$17.84
Renewable and Efficient Electric Power ...
Gilbert M. Masters
Hardcover - 680 pages
Design of Smart Power Grid Renewable Energy ...
Ali Keyhani
Hardcover - 592 pages
$131.57 Solar Electricity Handbook - 2014 Edition: ... Mr Michael Boxwell Paperback - 200 pages Integration of Distributed Generation in ... Math H. Bollen, ... Hardcover - 528 pages$114.39
Renewable Fuel Standard: Potential Economic ...
Committee on Economic ...
Paperback - 250 pages
$68.00 Power System Relaying Stanley H. Horowitz, ... Hardcover - 398 pages$130.77
Energy Systems Engineering: Evaluation and ...
Francis Vanek, Louis ...
Hardcover - 532 pages
Small Geothermal Energy Systems and ...
U.S. Government, ...
Kindle Edition - 226 pages
Power from Pellets: Technology and ...
Stefan Döring
Hardcover - 223 pages
\$159.00

## Have some knowledge to share

If you have some expert knowledge or experience, why not consider sharing this with our community.

By writing an electrical note, you will be educating our users and at the same time promoting your expertise within the engineering community.

To get started and understand our policy, you can read our How to Write an Electrical Note